[Accepted] Proposal: Refunding addresses that failed to migrate

Hello everyone,

Due to the accidental premature closing of the migration window there were two groups of addresses which failed to migrate:

  1. Addresses with VNL v1 who just didn’t migrate in time. (347,783 VNL total)
  2. Addresses which mined new VNL after the latest snapshot that was published. (13,811 VNL total)

Collectively these two groups account for 361,594 VNL that has failed to migrate (I’ll get an exact figure later).

Considering the migration window closed prematurely due to a scheduling error, I think the best long-term course of action is to make sure these people get their VNL “back”. Refunding them doesn’t impact anyone else negatively, but it does demonstrate that we as a community are watching out for each other, which is what I would personally want from a community I’m a part of.

So, I would propose that we refund these two groups from the VanillaDAO and all agree that we’ll mint this same amount back to the DAO in the next migration. This way everyone gets the amount of VNL if they could have migrated and once this amount is minted to the DAO, the supply becomes what it should have been.

What do you guys think?

P.s. Huge thank you to all of you for the insane amounts of support you continue to give us. We are trying very hard to be worthy of it!

2 Likes

Here are all the addresses and amounts of the eligible receivers who will be refunded in this proposal (in descending order of refunded amount):

  1. 0xd58E72Dc32077907F9a20c37fECd306F2a99ffE7: 173106.431778765862
  2. 0x3Be456f6b708cB24436BC59D860d7F3C9C6Cf6aa: 21600.441675643308
  3. 0xEA127321Ba91a126A7551E0ab341468488443705: 17973.13751530164
  4. 0xD96B3f42F4D4f65B9bb7b76aD9382062D550D8eb: 14118.729789387533
  5. 0xf61d051cC7753f5ea2a1c1ee9000D935a11a0a3B: 10732.643331280186
  6. 0xE8D508f29bb8685B5e749C181cDbea28F98e698E: 6965.777358965641
  7. 0xe740E441Cc81F073567d5C82fa9bc3334A001c1b: 6847.186283002765
  8. 0x4268E49fe3da0342E73b4871e438F4b71295E874: 6506.018085540826
  9. 0xF2542557fD733176D2e0add8bE13750DE2Cd67cE: 6342.289184389028
  10. 0x6509684a90a36F5A96a40D5132fB0ef68ceF696a: 4709.98915486221
  11. 0x4640c623F1Ef29ceDafEE082858b247bc21BD89f: 4003.581888505507
  12. 0x738726961dabef11514eC9b75E0665eE0050EbC4: 4002.982810089674
  13. 0xe168E767AD0E50b88c10bB19B12bC80F1B92cCd5: 3401.831337061819
  14. 0x3F4DE7A32b628fcCad9269a5f01516E81436f1Cb: 3109.991840788109
  15. 0x064c2e8eCe816C932A94334804Bf6ebF4b174021: 3108.155251939934
  16. 0x3945aFE04397AB1480127Adad111d93017F0ACD0: 2731.875993619174
  17. 0xd0e156B45f6E57718F2d9d6Cf780b5a5392f2f7B: 2239.636542298548
  18. 0x42ad79b6b9DFb804f71529FD590B2b33bBebb84E: 2030.873197627991
  19. 0x9a4b2D96697F235785Ccc337dB77c758Ae191B0a: 2028.359132364977
  20. 0xa81D50239B25B41Ae762F481dA4DFE2F988A9211: 2000
  21. 0x1281e0Ae1Ef8B756F760b3af2f1e2F04B9aF59ea: 1994.82504008967
  22. 0xB032ec905759B464A75EBbD41703CCcebAE77934: 1945.973955646186
  23. 0xA32323D138b280FCd78b771cfCE076BA78F4E3CD: 1922.695394165579
  24. 0x33938097b1D655761eAB28ED7dc8bc8A657267b9: 1885.636014099257
  25. 0xBE92C9f691AE66D8abD90A7e0B9f9b8609Cc4895: 1875.342048405697
  26. 0x88e4F2B28617f8eeA8025C3055C360A59BeC69ce: 1373.136931368456
  27. 0x09B9F5E1B0ec5585c1aE82a14a3d6089bFF2F0c6: 1206.558846156581
  28. 0x92aCdb54A04523c40966216bbD45890f74454B77: 1201.197022745901
  29. 0x558a0fe2f05F3bd4215903183D61aeFb8EcFf03E: 1116.629340345645
  30. 0xF4F02BBedEc2a192f2B371578Df8a65450ECc980: 1103.941869147854
  31. 0x55f8538e0ea2Eb6fd360be49E99Aefb9b86a7462: 1075.674809489746
  32. 0x6f454FA5C8c9dC56209f6f5D4c7dF32c735C4946: 1000
  33. 0x6ca1fF3B4e05785383E9DB09f7Ca4BA37ED1BBfC: 1000
  34. 0x81570EB2795d0bDE320Ee18A3aF2E71f54F7379e: 1000
  35. 0x59Ee569D8dc80b7edba29356cb21cf077536F1A2: 1000
  36. 0x6f5C4Ed232A975B9Cc0fBD8e93E2b264Bea1F6dF: 1000
  37. 0x6dc307694b01c343E93836b8783Df6d8c5B29125: 826.333063808198
  38. 0x6B15AE1946b36Fac6f93F16F026EC6F32dE0D64c: 807.045325762611
  39. 0xe599483CB4cc902Ef4012FCf881c23FEa52Ff380: 737.63008629446
  40. 0xD8a830894eeA1eE8DaEAa8D62ED18a2a9CA64Ae8: 695.918353457056
  41. 0x821d36d88E2B693BFe8b05B21366cedac1720011: 664.914175426934
  42. 0xA22564a691BD18384597301079B015906eCaF0E9: 653.623503411266
  43. 0xC5fa8BD65DDC93a5b253E7D801aea62FC08Fc5C3: 609.90066877005
  44. 0x7472b9e36dfdb8b0e939D0A7107750f772Fc9908: 600
  45. 0x5f91EC6c2F2Ab1CFb8F5Be097F49302Dc8c6e43F: 596.936155117985
  46. 0x5965578cA01b0842752D37e0923D9da351A21737: 568.977127278036
  47. 0x9f97DdC68B4b2122474f59ff6E9Df25a4C2e882C: 566.033621729955
  48. 0xf8Db88ac13365756FEe9B70c4E94aF18a6aDe869: 533.696180860698
  49. 0x4B1CBCADcfCEbC3Bd5997efCdfe65549321b2E68: 509.107244510856
  50. 0x440Ca9e8971d9af0344FE2d48300fAB4dD21B9Eb: 503.215028073922
  51. 0xBFe07A21ccc5Cdc5D94067E9002B9A60217B96c6: 500
  52. 0xafb7e19a422216b2c496EC9b59dc46CdAD9DD48a: 458.006689277228
  53. 0x14A1d2Fca64360967165EE4A4a21AD0A850514ce: 435.706978985696
  54. 0x65f04ae55e01F38FeeE66F0Cc29b77692F9BE3EE: 427.717127536168
  55. 0x3779F6232A04c068d8988Ea595E83E1d1843Ffd7: 420.197999770468
  56. 0x87b1328adC6F1ADC5FC6c0c5DB5CaA72A3e54775: 416.5316836563
  57. 0xA9D4413c8Dc7ddd9B430EC98d93c7d0D40385FAd: 405.841462802512
  58. 0xa41A2355f46084096eB6394D51f9E3B04c444599: 400.05783930624
  59. 0xB2287B8b48aeB743A44F24505129bf6AFC56543c: 400
  60. 0x0D0ACA99686fcEd8e6FB39134AaeD96F09b5283c: 396.994623719278
  61. 0x267DEa79A3509811209b48E7700619B117aCA699: 392.893137529844
  62. 0xF1e4f4336293D5902A428666C117Cb6096d70990: 373.534831381323
  63. 0x841594982480e80Df7A0191ac9e4eF435932DbfC: 365.914622157491
  64. 0xac22381D670ef87e5432EEfc1D0079A8E87C9fF8: 361.004395480953
  65. 0x39961520e442Af7735Ad49aED06a1e9173371eF9: 357.194511139329
  66. 0x0dF97D3f344fe39cBBD5A2eF59763a9F60b9cff4: 353.273805910609
  67. 0x0E0fA1f3d4A343758113269ACa0394b72e391cac: 352.671027936388
  68. 0xa3020dF768D66049671d3A895A072e5B9E9f4Daa: 344.370556569064
  69. 0x9Ec87B05f8eCFCcb4ddFD3e726a9eA73Ca167Ef8: 338.466249455254
  70. 0x274CAB5F3cc27df54D3f065E2D704a87aAef0cC0: 315.547944499372
  71. 0x64463eC252493Ca5E7AE083bf820568DEc1ED1DA: 311.855254623277
  72. 0x0c2317Cf931e1Ff23001588E57D97Ca8d0522b2B: 306.987403996153
  73. 0x164458Cf50Ea507E5eA11b80723eD8113403FAd2: 303.054941605685
  74. 0x175d73cF1A452cA3Edc468878Cc4f05ad46B6A83: 302.769507442733
  75. 0x2b0CfB12ED66d6f592E61B742F1444FA5d1cC233: 300
  76. 0x51eEEF0155Bf4869C178F5d9c1d8871b11A6F99f: 296.523521817586
  77. 0x2DE9143fb158996cCEd9e6cf72aab4a9e7111599: 294.914574333424
  78. 0x0C2fdd43160076B0C73657759c26d951893ca3e8: 275
  79. 0x3a6baCC445CBCBf6A56F62Aa47AE6aD211B9A43D: 272.545376255024
  80. 0x8215597fbF60b738458266140B706f591152caFF: 266.818979574353
  81. 0xCDE381003b8E1B7169F7eB3f55f484dD1136b190: 250
  82. 0xac57b5996B9796640Cc8Dd56050037fa239e8469: 247.083643907942
  83. 0xFd031e761CdEe2CbC974CE84827ED262a770884f: 242.497518427691
  84. 0x0ae05ecFAf2ee11e03c89Eaa96785A2e9505e218: 237.174844016631
  85. 0x35F105E802DA60D3312e5a89F51453A0c46B9Dad: 234.582989833379
  86. 0xf7b8017a8fcF6C8C5Ea5a762D751F8124a3A5A63: 229.572761486518
  87. 0x083632CD42e25c41206f3f18D334939715adF2E8: 222.269487316551
  88. 0xA9Aa6759bA479Fd980212403E36dF8488326c38e: 217.462950977799
  89. 0x07217AbAf71CF29b24eBda3C469Df8481FE368Bc: 215.110692391299
  90. 0x5Ecf2bF841c0E1BBbf09682f06B1507F6aF86915: 211.57236581089
  91. 0xa925e3D1aEb3bcE1a23a74C6e96a54b50cF45782: 206.438911945763
  92. 0xBEe1314a430D80aEa224860B020dce7eC25Eed98: 201.129738894493
  93. 0x4Bf396104eBDa46f8Dd5849C3D1a94483bCeFA29: 200
  94. 0x29BA9A205d7db2Adce40764fBe2eF176A181A484: 194.647453076406
  95. 0x4579DF06DaF502D05dB64fEfA82F58c8B2430002: 192.738192892246
  96. 0xeD8b9A58e92a53f63d07195A85c0FfFe0E4CD0cC: 191.201350816733
  97. 0xe30DE63e681b107592048AE2e5CE3d5573c11632: 186.164887071145
  98. 0x61EB3C4a3B0f64BF6BE8B234e50F1853bc27754A: 185.75850607363
  99. 0xb0D1b2941B8dfFA993184d8e62d424cCAbaFC460: 183.070947882835
  100. 0x62c107ef172fCF6C8eDDd1f36C852dC313037F59: 173.818748274754
  101. 0x4c3F6e7014CD210Cfd35a250F6aEe54f36ae99da: 167.963695927212
  102. 0xAf7392A4FD8C582D819c8b5d21b7a9Dc5413986d: 162.142290868545
  103. 0x4A107db3D886a8a85d022349A387d6A89FA92E5a: 160.290051320024
  104. 0x2395e2C40F8974104550b7E9f68edcc292A6E23a: 156.298109740129
  105. 0x685501524856aEbd9B1022bD076e8f913F02d347: 151.741496747509
  106. 0x6B2aF7838478835716dD0Cbed7567a15CA0941BB: 151
  107. 0xB763F041FB7B387006EeBf0b9eBB2A87fBD45dbA: 150.372715726007
  108. 0x7181B9a218fad0B57519C765E8728f2CeC9EC06C: 146.537380897011
  109. 0xF014B40ef9976e97405EA3Bbf66009D6018EeF3B: 145.210738593534
  110. 0x1890318901ff74407A324C33dC966f33340c5E61: 144.431243005744
  111. 0x5E50B04e78144A4c7BED40cD78fdEe537D928CCa: 140.571835597241
  112. 0xbdA4341Fa716486A4ddBe10Cd168dF843F5D6d33: 123
  113. 0x1D121d8a6C764a0eB832294579bBBa70aEBDc2D3: 117.459413922157
  114. 0x139CcCBbE190c90Ea7903bB28ED2a3A79CC83952: 116.560110818314
  115. 0x43018918F5a5eD8BBdBAA46066A017aad0886BdB: 112.845396915352
  116. 0x5972dA5FF1B91a83fce2cdA94Ad8601DC0eB14B3: 111.155186091017
  117. 0x1f92Bd05b5E1022354e2c7760B5A03aa56f8687E: 108.976658057599
  118. 0xEB06A52B5AD831eE265aDE07bDA1309c63C0400f: 104.555734647605
  119. 0x0A81b2c730684fb2228E0A1418Ad9a375ebd82DA: 104.358990108508
  120. 0x244806e7Efc0F40856668d9D12534a34d15B1d8c: 102.295312373844
  121. 0x6B6D28AC44674e11137e4C826A3DdA53162198F1: 101
  122. 0x98B559863919e3b7eb9dAe5b83aFdB1F233837b6: 100
  123. 0xa7FBc801e5D0be65EF8337AbEFed9F8f72042352: 100
  124. 0xCE6a52ee9f9b6EdA89BAdEd55e1d47895eEa7649: 100
  125. 0xDF14100B76a5b5fd46FbA22b7Ac124919CFfC92a: 100
  126. 0xC9B22861E6acF0fc2316eb7a7608e8D2Be4847DA: 100
  127. 0x5034227994573Cc8921138b4b09aC354a813741F: 99.961447337668
  128. 0x059E51c98C0a5B89624E8C1937a001DbEaCEda8c: 86.198357902425
  129. 0x11eDedebF63bef0ea2d2D071bdF88F71543ec6fB: 84.208136263801
  130. 0x675ddaA6B7cfB944daA28a99f0B6f4559dCB2BB0: 82.770836250695
  131. 0x6013125bCC1A9026F63937e3c9788fAf16966F6c: 82.586275815313
  132. 0xC18D0091c06D8E3BF2d7d60f73cFd66CbB96A5C3: 80
  133. 0x961B8d72658bb8Bf7AFfEe016c67B661Db30cABc: 78.273600966096
  134. 0xE6a01a89EB512192C9694e0f31631f2bb1aBc69d: 70.048601872752
  135. 0x5459E0A8000573Fd6921da4096665213Ba5aE873: 69.619791432986
  136. 0x3C6aEaE12e300cf55FFf3d905D356215F9B2c318: 65.057157134134
  137. 0x7299B91174F79C820aA1Ed787F6C719A20AbcA95: 63.717229026795
  138. 0xAdcF01b3b41384C3B524470cDD3Ae6d65c1F452F: 61.195943922007
  139. 0xC49d4729282F9D6880742e01d9e6a61f1C97f61A: 59.277630993077
  140. 0x09416E8721E3446E9e8e7026b667088273d6011b: 51.501767449602
  141. 0x4738c8b9e0d7b48db4056BF017D2F90b2319630d: 50
  142. 0xD03e2dCC8C1E25987C06CC5151A16dC662E2a341: 46.137367103515
  143. 0xB4f3Dd88Fd6baf12695837045E51f91346bED883: 40.6504065
  144. 0x93C72384498c6Ff777E5bBF1154edFD2324B47aF: 40.291516428074
  145. 0x93a1Fff543dC5A2F6ae6543a1c827d3991e17a3A: 37
  146. 0x7c8FAA39C83d790DEA6D0F03Ce1Cf23b903c3AC1: 34.738965070934
  147. 0x8EAB1ec8300027027b3DD370bc0DFA87D9165DD7: 24.40693834368
  148. 0x2452f33D10956C7b115110278165166a83766622: 20.546189222295
  149. 0x5F91cB7B9f15BD8D2A49787a385Cd91F3777F99A: 19.832192948507
  150. 0x886Ec2DC3AcE0B9B1673B7802f18c4C154De27f5: 18.706824389807
  151. 0x4bFd81BE14041c0490626Fc9024C5db4Ad5BC5Fe: 14.182227629106
  152. 0x2c4170682D709F548b7F2b51599f025Caafa25F8: 9
  153. 0x75A329EE96860333B15E3E9B0ad5b46cE5268740: 5.038634160214
  154. 0x035662be6Fe7f58940adb92c578282097D6725Dc: 3.086113147262
  155. 0x1E0B4E82bD847DaE91d2E0BF6255522B24622485: 0.975625591138
  156. 0xc6144b1B3f04e766C4F9bb5F315fFE04795F697B: 0.846571653859
  157. 0x959cF5E36b65536d311316e4517fF63b08910A17: 0.783946852746
  158. 0x722a3e4B2e409Ced71134eD92d946432741a1D4B: 0.75862992213
  159. 0xD42c5bC6fa89507a5f9c9eed7Ff2F8d9Ada093E1: 0.101747572282
  160. 0x237ec64cC27196F6a4C16AbdBb558B4C518400C2: 0.001484926288

These receivers match the Etherscan Token Balance page with all the 8 contract addresses in the list excluded:

  • the biggest holder is our VNL v1.1- token contract where all migrated VNL v1 tokens are frozen - holding a total of 10647340.020936175431 VNL v1 tokens
  • 7 of the smallest holders are also contracts which are the Uniswap v2 VNL-WETH pool and some unidentified contracts which do not appear to be multisigs or other human-controlled contracts - holding a total of 0.000000000117 VNL v1 tokens

Therefore, the total refund will be 347783.833514642328 VNL v1.1. This also includes everyone who profit-mined after the latest snapshot and were unable to migrate (the group 2). The refund will be transferred from the VanillaDAOs balance to all eligible receivers in a single transaction.

Now, obviously this will be a big transaction and it’s crucial to get all the numbers correct, but we minimized the chance of human error by generating the numbers programmatically from the mainnet state, and double-checked the generated numbers manually. Still, if you find any inconsistencies or errors, please let us know asap either in this thread or pinging admins in the Telegram.

2 Likes

The refund transaction was approved and executed by the Vanilla DAO (Etherscan link).

hey im number 056 in the list and didnt recieve a refund can anyone check into this for me

Hi! Checked the refund for account number 56 and according to Etherscan there’s a correct VNL transfer from DAO to that address, so all should be good.

It may be worth to note that the refund receivers have actually two distinct tokens with a similar symbol VNL - VNL v1.1 which is the real VNL and which was transferred in this refund (Etherscan) and the VNL v1 which is now useless (Etherscan). Because of this, some people might need to reconfigure their wallets, if they originally added VNL as a custom asset and it still refers the to old v1 address.